Jul
Selling to Procurement
Question: Why bother?
No really, why bother?
Let’s face it procurement or purchasing specialists, not people sales professionals want to deal with. As the economy tightens and companies re-examine their spending, reclassify things in terms of crucial or discretionary, the role of these professionals becomes even more critical and frequent. They make more decisions in a vacuum where value is a distant second to price, Procurement Specialist wield more power than ever before.
There is no minimizing the impact they have on sales and the success of sales professionals. Sales professionals are constantly looking for ways to sell to these procurement folks, that special technique or special words that will help them overcome this perceived hurdle. How do we sell to Procurement? A question we hear over and over.
Well the bad news is there is no special incantation, technique or anything else that will magically change this “bad” reality. These people are there because they have the skills needed to succeed in their task.
Trying to sell to them using conventional means is analogous to one trying to inflict pain to an inanimate object like say a stump, or someone with no nerves in their body. You can kick, punch, stab, pinch slash, bust or burn. No nerves, no pain, no progress. Since they are immune to value, your value prop will fall on deaf ears, and you frustration level will rise to the point where you will make mistakes and greater harm to your ability to meet your objective.
This why we say “why bother?”
Your time is much better used employing a strategy and tactics to neutralize their impact and minimize their ability to negatively impact your efforts and objectives. How do you do this, by selling to the people who truly derive the “value” from your product; once they are sold, enlist them in helping you manage and marginalize the “procurement man” from with in.
Despite rumors to the contrary, procurement specialists are people, and as such you can talk to them, and learn many things, this is not going to happen in the middle of a transaction, but you can talk to them in other environments (conferences, trade shows, even those in your own company). What you learn is that they do have standards, and they do have objectives, and are measured on their success.
One thing I learned is that it is not just price that drives the whole thing, price is big, but there is more. One is the “real” need for the product and/or service you sell, will it really help in their company’s success. Key here is the “company”, not the individual. Often, as sales people we sell to individuals within a company, but those same individuals are unable to sell the ‘powers that be’, unable to show that there is a company need, rather than a nice to have. No matter how nice it may be for that one individual, they are unable to present a case that the benefit serves the broader need of the company, and as a result the initiative dies. The cause of death is reported as a number of things: “budget cut backs”, “other priorities”, “more cost effective solutions”, the reality however is that your “chumpion” was unable to generate enough support elsewhere in the organization, and gave up for fear of spending too much political capital on the wrong initiative.
I hear sales people tell me all the time that their “chumpion”, inside person really wants to buy, but they can’t seem to get past procurement. Yet when you ask them who else they have involved in the decision they say they don’t really want to “go around” the “chumpion”, it may cause them to get upset. Really? So what? It’s not like they are exactly getting you to where you need to be now, how much further behind can you get, if you are not getting the deal now, how can things get worse? The key is to build broad based support. Go and find the people who benefit from your product, directly, and even more importantly indirectly. Let’s say you sell research reports, you usually sell to research mangers, analysts, the occasional marketing director. Who do they work for? Who gets benefit from their output? After all your data may be part of some broader report, it is raw data that is processed by the above that makes its way into the decision process, say if, when, and how to launch a product. Who benefits if the decision is right, who suffers if the decision is wrong? On this level, who has a direct stake in the quality of the data and insights that go into the report on which they are betting their own and company’s success? If you reach out to those people, their peers and dependents, you will find the type of allies that have the ability to influence, move and marginalize Procurement. You will also find that when successful, your original “chumpion” will thank you, since they still get the halo effect of your success, and continue to benefit from the access to your product or service. Same can be done in software, hardware, logistics, you name it, and anywhere where your product can be tied to “critical” aspects of success, rather than labeled as a “nice to have”. The key is do you know who is the ultimate beneficiary of the output, will your “chumpion” attest their need to have your product or service, or can you make a compelling enough argument to the real stake holders that can help influence or manage procurement. One company we worked with began to target CFO’s, the strategy was to align their product, considered by most a commodity, to the company’s financial objectives: reduced over all cost; and to the company’s productivity objectives which included consolidation, automation and outsourcing of non-core or essential activities. Their competitors who continued to target their traditional buyers all lost business, all got stalled, and all had sympathetic “chumpions”. Our client was able to elevate their sale, and by engaging the CFO and positioning the decision to other criteria, found a real Champion when it came to procurement, the procurement director’s boss: the CFO. It is not easy, it does take work, not only in hunting down the right people and getting in front of them, but also in reinventing how you position and pitch your service and value to a client/prospect. On the other hand, once you do accomplish this reinvention, the dividends are big, long lasting and repeatable. One added bonus is that once you redefine yourself in this way, with the expanded more powerful audience, the size of your sale, market and wallet share also improve. It’s up to you, you can rationalize why you lost, or take the same effort, resources and energy to win. Sell Well,
Tibor Shanto, The Pipeline















This post has 5 comments
July 5th, 2008
Tibor, thank you for an informative and valuable article. I particularly enjoyed the term “Chumpion” – I think I may adopt it.
Finance Directors/Procurement Specialists are labelled with the “boogie man” reputation in sales because they above all have the ability offer one thing – reality. Like you say, these people are humans and their job is very much concerned with the longevity of their company as a whole. They don’t decline deals because they hate us, just that they don’t believe that our product is worth investing in over the financial positioning of the company.
Reality, says that you have to deal with finance controllers at some stage in the sales process, quite rightly by employing as much support as possible other than your “chumpion”. However, I wonder, how many sales people approach these people after they have scuppered a deal to understand how their product failed in the whole “value, cost and company picture” scenario. Like you said, these people are humans, why can’t they aid you in selling to them?
July 7th, 2008
Tibor,
I am glad to have found your blog. This will get trackedback on my site as it is inciteful and worth every sales person’s time to read. I try and teach people to enter a company as high up the food chain as possible. If one of the reps I work with explains that he is discussing an opportunity with a purchasing agent before the approval for the PO is there, I share with them that they have failed.
July 8th, 2008
Great post, I will get my editorial team to cover this over the Procurement Leaders Network – http://www.procurementleaders.com.
Cheers Mark
July 8th, 2008
Hi Tibor
Really enjoyed the post. I initially thought it was going to go down the “how to sneak behind procurement’s back” route – but instead, by teating them as humans and enlisting them as allies, you can have much more productive relationships.
Ian
July 11th, 2008
Great post… I really liked how you advised people to enter the organization as high as possible and to treat the procurement agent as a ally and tailor your proposal to explicit meet their needs.
Thanks for sharing!
-Brad
Trackbacks/Pingbacks
Brilliant - A new find in Tibor Shanto and a steady favorite in Colin Wilson | startup sales mentor blog-
-
Karl Goldfield
Back round the blogs… | Sales Excellence -
July 7th, 2008
[...] get right to it and start with an amazing post by Tibor Shanto. In his post, “Selling to procurement“, he clearly explains the futility in these efforts. There is no magic way to get purchasing [...]
July 7th, 2008
Selling to Procurement http://www.sellbetter.ca/blog/?p=41
This comment was originally posted on TwitterJuly 8th, 2008
[...] sales blog is called “The Pipeline”. His latest post is an excellent treatise on Selling to Procurement
Trackbacks